Thread: Advice on converting my VMC
My advise is don't buy any of that lot from Automation or Kelling cnc as it used to be known.? You'll be paying far more than need to for only average components. (the fact your looking here makes me suspect you've been around our american cousins on cnczone.?)
First the Drives are just rebadged cheap chinese drives and for less money you could by Leadshine drives that are much better and higher voltage. Like AM882 or EM806.
Also take note you keep showing links for drives that are only capable of 50Vdc max. Even the higher 8056D can only handle 70Vdc Max which means allowing for safety factor you'll need to run them around 60Vdc.
The PSU is fine (except it's too large for those drives) but you could easily build the same thing for half the price. Very easy to build as many on here will tell you.
The motors are ok but do you really need 34's.? What size machine is it.?
Regards the 24Vdc and noise(EMF) then this is mostly for control circuits. The CSlabs only works with 24Vdc so you'll still need 24 supply but only small 2-3A switch mode affair for e-stop, limits etc.
The higher voltage lowers the chance of EMF affecting signal lines and when used with correct shielded cable you'll have very stable system. Coupled with high quality of Cslabs controller you'll be very noise immune.
Last edited by JAZZCNC; 3 Weeks Ago at 04:26 PM.
The Following User Says Thank You to JAZZCNC For This Useful Post:
3 Weeks Ago #42
Thanx Jazzcnc for advice and comments :-)
And yes, i am a member of CncZone as well. There are some Norwegian members there, and i like to hear all those different opinions ;-)
Ok, it seems i was a bit offline when i replyed to the thread. Mentioned KL-8056D but provided a link to KL-5056D.
I did send Automation a mail last night asking why the they list KL-8056D for "up to +7Vdc", when the datasheet say +20 to +80Vdc.
If what i have read around is correct, the KL-8056D is a re-badged Leadshine DM870. And Leadshine says +20 to +72Vdc in their datasheet(found that out today)
Dissapointing and very confusing, but this fact eliminates the KL-8056D.
Tried to find a price for the AM882 and EM806 and they don`t come cheap. Found some new AM882 at a reasonable price though and may decide on them.
What about the MA860H? Does anybody have any experience with the MA860H ?
Leadshine datasheet says input voltage of max 80Vac or +110Vdc, 7,2A. Price 58,88 on steppers-online.
I do have a lot of experience with PSU(both switched and lineary) Jazzcnc, and having a larger than necessary PSU only ensure less voltage drop at high loads.
Besides i want to have enough for the 4th axis.(might even put in the 5th axis in time if i get if i get excessively geeky ).
And beleive me Jazzcnc, i have searched the entire Norweginan marked for parts to build it my self. That will cost me twice as much.
The reason for me choosing Nema34 motors is only because it has Nema34 motors originally. (Lacy me, don`t have to manufacture new mounting brackets)
Final thoughts with renewed thanx to good advice from Jazzcnc:
AM882 or MA860H(Havent decided yet.
KL34H280-45-4A or 34HS38-3008S(Havent decided yet, and yes).
Motion COntroller and PSU will still be CSMIO/IP-S and KL-7220.
I do beleive this should summarize a good setup, unless there is something i don`t see(again)
And again, thanx for advice and comments gents
Ok first lets drop the Jazzcnc just call me Dean others do and I don't mind.
If you want AC Digital drives then there's model AM882-H
Now Current is different matter and I was talking about voltage.!
I'm very surprised you can't find toridal Transformer and 3 x capacitors cheaper than $200.!!
Last edited by JAZZCNC; 3 Weeks Ago at 05:24 PM.
3 Weeks Ago #44
Will be setting up a multichannel(24) National Instruments DAQ/ADC system analyzing the signals when i run the tool change.
That should give me a "time map" for all signals initiated with mS or even uS timing, and compare it to the schematics of the system.
Which again would give me insight to compare it to all the options with the CSMIO/IP-S unit.
Talked to Rob(The Engine Guy) at the Zone who bought a VMC300, and the guy owning it before him used a Koyo Direct Logic PLC to program and run the ATC.
That makes me wonder if i shouldn`t be able to do the same with the CSMIO/IP-S. And even with Mach compatibility.
Will start to tear down all the old electronics after taht, prepping the VMC for new shiny parts. Can`t wait :-)
Last edited by Proteus; 3 Weeks Ago at 08:13 PM.
M6 in G-code tells mach to turn on output #? and wait until input #? goes high or low then carry on with Job. The PLC is programmed to do the tool change when it sees Mach's output on it's input. Then when finished turn on it's Output which mach see's on it's Input. The shows goes on.!
Common for ATC's to use PLC for tool change. That said for ATC's which don't require massive amounts of I/O Macro works just as well. The Cslabs as plenty of I/O and don't think this ATC needs lots of I/O so don't see the point my self.
I think the guy who used the PLC will have done so because he didn't have enough I/O. This is one reason why the Cslabs are so good for retrofits because they come with plenty of I/O and can easily be increased without costing the earth.
Last edited by JAZZCNC; 3 Weeks Ago at 08:45 PM.
3 Weeks Ago #47
Last edited by JoeHarris; 3 Weeks Ago at 09:59 PM.
3 Weeks Ago #48
Also, my experience of buying from China has been pretty good so far too. Like anywhere there are good and bad sellers.
3 Weeks Ago #49
Can't say i understood that comment JoeHarris.
Just trying to figure out the ATC myself. I had a lot of help with some of my questions in this forum, but as a newbie i feel like understanding the functions myself as well.
Besides, if you read my post to Dean you would know i bought the AM882 ;-)
Last edited by Proteus; 3 Weeks Ago at 10:39 PM.
3 Weeks Ago #50
By Marv2097 in forum Boxford Vertical MillsReplies: 15Last Post: 20-09-2016, 08:58 AM
By T0rnado69 in forum Emco Milling MachinesReplies: 14Last Post: 09-09-2014, 11:24 AM
By motoxy in forum Computer SoftwareReplies: 7Last Post: 28-02-2014, 07:11 AM
By motoxy in forum SketchupReplies: 3Last Post: 08-07-2012, 11:04 AM
By Yow Ling in forum General DiscussionReplies: 12Last Post: 15-11-2010, 09:18 AM