Thread: Oh crumbs. Here we go!
Blimey a big thumbs up to Chai, unbelievable service, guess what turned up on my doorstep this morning, all the way from China, less than a week after ordering?
I was like a kid at Christmas this morning. Only problem now is that I was expecting it to take at least a couple more weeks to arrive and hopefully I'd have been well on the way to completing some sort of design! Which I haven't!
What I have managed to do is think a bit about my YAxis, and have come up with a couple of ideas, nothing revolutionary and not anything that you'll not have seen before, and this is where the questions start to flow.
Up until now I've been hoping to use aluminium extrusion, for ease and simplicity, but having another browse through the other builds got thinking about using aluminium plate. Is there any advantage of using plate? On my second design in the pics attached to this post I think this would work better with aluminium plate, instead of using the extrusion and then I was thinking I could move the ball screw onto the same side as the rails. My only concern is the extra cost involved in getting the pieces made up. What are the comparative costs in buying a 750mm length of extrusion and say a 750x300x20mm plate? Is 20mm thick enough as a back plate for a Y Axis?
Of my two initial ideas below I'm leaning towards the first one as it just looks stronger, but am all ears as to any thoughts, advice on improvements, amendments, materials etc etc.
Last edited by hoppo; 18-10-2012 at 02:23 PM.
From the picture, unless it's a twin start screw, it looks like you got RM1605 for the longest screw, not RM1610. Assuming the ballscrew is 1150mm long, as per the original post, this will limit you to about 8.5m/min due to the critical speed. That speed is plenty, but I doubt you will get it with 3Nm motors unless you have a 2:1 ratio between the motor and the ballscrew to get 10mm 'effective pitch'.
20mm is plenty thick enough as a back plate for the Y-axis, so long as you have some box section or extrusion bolted to it to increase the strength parallel to X and the torsional stiffness. It will be much more rigid if you have the ballscrew directly between the rails, so on the same side is good.
The Following User Says Thank You to Jonathan For This Useful Post:
I'm wondering the same as I design my gantry hoppo, a top & bottom mounting for the rails I think would provide a slimmer gantry so the router bit will be closer to the gantry but it also seems to sacrifice some gantry stiffness when compared to side mounting the rails.
Assuming all other materials and dimensions etc stay the same, does a top/bottom mounting of linear rails give better real world performance or side-mounted ones?
Hi Jonathan, thanks for your post. It is indeed a single start RM1605 and 1150mm in length. I was planning on trying to drive it directly with a Nema 23 3Nm stepper but after your post I'll now somehow implement using pulleys to drive the x axis. So much yet to learn, but hey that's half the fun! On the subject of ratios will the RM1605's be ok for the shorter Y and Z axis's being driven directly? I saw a post on here that recommended this site Bearing Station - Adhesives, Bearings, Belts, Chains, O Rings, Oil Seals, Pulleys & Sprockets so I'll start to have a look at what would work, unless you've got any other recommendations. I was also beginning to think of using two screws, instead of one along the x axis. Would this make a difference or if I did go down this route would you still advise on using a 2:1 ratio but on both screws?
I've decided to definitely use aluminium plate for the Y axis, it just looks and feels more solid, and the prices are comparable, having looked on aluminium warehouse. Would I need to use ecocast for the backplate or would 6082 do the job? I'll probably be looking for someone to machine the sides for me, and then I'll drill it tap it and bolt it together. Anyhow I've attached my idea for the Y axis. As usual any comments appreciated. And also as usual many thanks for all the help so far. I'm sure there'll be loads more questions.
Learning myself so could be wrong but from what I have seen & read ally plate on it's own won't be enough for the gantry & you will need some extrusion or box section fixed to it.
Hey Martin, yes I think you're right. Jonathan also mentioned it in an earlier post on this thread. I plan on bolting a bit of steel box section across the backplate of the gantry to give it that extra rigidity. Do you know if that applies to the sides too?
Was just about to order some aluminium plate to start building my z axis. Had a bit of a panic. Is 15mm thick enough or would I be better off using 20mm for the sliding part and the back plate?
In answer to an earlier question - standard 6082 is fine for supported rails. Tooling plate is only really worthwhile for proper linear guides.
No easy way to say this but your Z axis looks particularly -er- "unlikely". I think you may be just about to make a big mistake.
Basically, the fixed part of the Z above the bed should be at max material thickness + a tadge for clearance.
The Z axis travel should be max material thickness + max tool length + a tadge for clearance.
Do not over-estimate these maximums because you think it will limit the machine. Over-estimation leads to overhangs that will weaken it so much it may not want to cut anything harder than cheese.
OTOH I haven't read the whole of this thread. If you are planning on cutting foam patterns with a 6" tool it looks fine and dandy apart from the minimal vertical separation on the Z blocks.
Cheers for the tips Robin, I'm still a while off finalising the plans yet and very much in the design stage still, and when I get round to picking up the design again I'll try to implement your good advice. In the meantime I have made progress in other areas. Namely I've managed to pick up 3 drivers from Wantai (DQ860MA) and built myself a power supply to power them which I'm quite proud of. Testing it out with a few Nema 17 steppers that I have for a different project all seems to work rather well. I've only been driving them back and forwards using an arduino to supply the pulses so far, but all seems good so far. I'll step up to using that old pc that I have lying around eventually but I'll need to find a hard drive for it first and install Mach 3 or similar. To be continued....