Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
  1. #1
    cncJim's Avatar
    Lives in Reading, United Kingdom. Last Activity: 2 Weeks Ago Has been a member for 4-5 years. Has a total post count of 170. Received thanks 15 times, giving thanks to others 32 times.
    Ok so my cnc is generally great (for my very very simple needs!) but it does have 1 major failing that i would like to improve. The gantry is made up from 2 20mm round bars spanning approx. 7-800mm and it supporting a 1.5kW chinese spindle and associated mounts. You can imagine what happens - tons of flex/ruined parts - most noticeable when trying to cut sharp 90 deg turns from y to x, ends up with a lovely big curve if I go to fast!

    Here is a rough diagram.
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Drawing1.jpg 
Views:	166 
Size:	25.5 KB 
ID:	10489

    I also had a situation cutting a long thin pocket running down the x axis - all was going fine until suddenly the spindle seemed to flex down as if was trying to dig into the wood! I guess this was the flexing issue allowing this to happen...

    So my question is how could I possibly improve my situation with minimum cost/rework?

    Two ideas I thought of are:-
    * upgrade the round rail to a larger diameter.
    * change the round rail to supported round rail - I was thinking I could grid off part of the support at each end of the rail so it would fit in the existing holes?

    Any ideas?

  2. #2
    I suppose you have to first establish exactly where the flexing is taking place, it's maybe not where you first think of.
    What about attaching a wide piece of aluminium extrusion or box section from one side piece to the other then fasten supported rail to that.

  3. #3
    cncJim's Avatar
    Lives in Reading, United Kingdom. Last Activity: 2 Weeks Ago Has been a member for 4-5 years. Has a total post count of 170. Received thanks 15 times, giving thanks to others 32 times.
    Quote Originally Posted by EddyCurrent View Post
    I suppose you have to first establish exactly where the flexing is taking place, it's maybe not where you first think of.
    Valid point - I admit the only reason for picking on the gantry as being the issue is based on my complex scientific testing - I grabbed the spindle, yanked it around until it flexed! I all feels very rigid except for flexing the spindle up and down.

    Quote Originally Posted by EddyCurrent View Post
    What about attaching a wide piece of aluminium extrusion or box section from one side piece to the other then fasten supported rail to that.
    That could work really well! Thanks for the idea :)

  4. #4
    Jim this is not what your going to want to hear but I'm saying it anyway.!! . . . . Don't bother and start again.

    I say this with lots of experience helping folks who took the route your about to take only to regret it later. ONLY out come from taking this route is wasted money and time. Outcome is ALWAYS the same lots of work and still ending with under performing machine.

    Honestly don't let others talk you into trying to improve it's false economy that never ends well.

  5. #5
    cncJim's Avatar
    Lives in Reading, United Kingdom. Last Activity: 2 Weeks Ago Has been a member for 4-5 years. Has a total post count of 170. Received thanks 15 times, giving thanks to others 32 times.
    Thanks for the advice Jazz. I generally agree with what you have said and I can see that my post may have sounded like it came from some blinkered fool blind to reality, but I would say (or hope!) that maybe my situation may be slightly different?....

    I can't really start again as I didn't start in the first place! :) I acquired my machine as result of getting carried away on ebay. It was mainly in bits and there was no real info about it but I went for it anyway hoping that if I couldn't get it working I could sell it one for more than I paid.

    Lucky for me some cleaning and bolting together was all that was needed :)

    I don't think I have the skills (and with 3 kids certainly not the time!) required to put together the kind of machine I would love to own from scratch.

    What do I use it for? Well, I have made a nice Aztec jobby for my dad, some vcut signs for friends, a drilling template for my fireplace and thin ply puzzle type toys for my children (I would also like to try some PCBs at some point). I am the first to admit that none of my projects have been perfect (far from it!), but all have been good enough for purpose and for the time and effort I put in.

    The only issue I encounter is with the flexing which sometimes costs me time/wood/bits to try and workaround. If I could improve this without spending to much time/effort (100 and a few hours?) then in my eyes, it would be worth it. But if its not possible to improve then I would still be happy with my machine and continue using it with workarounds.

    Anyway, thanks again for replying :)

  6. #6
    Quote Originally Posted by cncJim View Post
    I can't really start again as I didn't start in the first place! :) I acquired my machine as result of getting carried away on ebay.
    Arghh the dreaded Flee bay strikes again . .Lol . . . .Well in that case then.!!!. . . . . Nothing changes still don't bother and stick it back on Ebay.

    Without good foundations no amount of money will help and with unsupported rails you have very poor foundations so 100 won't go far or help much at all.


    By the way don't think you or anyone else new to building CNC and taking this route are fools.!! . . .I class you and others who have done the same has Maze victims.??? . . . . .You where Duped into a Big Maze with NO exit so end up resorting to digging to get out.!! . . . Not until the problems have been highlighted and explained then decided to ignore sound advise do I consider people fools.!! . . . . . Unfortunately There have been many struck off the list and re-classed has fools.! . . . . . . . . . Don't start digging Jim only way is down and don't want to see you on my list of fools either. .
    Last edited by JAZZCNC; 23-10-2013 at 06:46 PM.

  7. #7
    cncJim's Avatar
    Lives in Reading, United Kingdom. Last Activity: 2 Weeks Ago Has been a member for 4-5 years. Has a total post count of 170. Received thanks 15 times, giving thanks to others 32 times.
    Haha! I'll do my best to stay off your list of fools Jazz! No guarantees mind!

    Would you mind taking a look at the parts of my machine and give me your opinion? I don't anticipate that I can economically improve the machine but I would like to learn more on what to look for in the future.

    My machine's frame is made from approx. 100mm x 40mm welded steel box section
    X axis is 1200mm of 25mm unsupported rail
    Y axis is 2 x 700mm of 20mm unsupported rail
    4 x Zapp steppers
    Ballscrews on all
    1.5kW Chinese Spindle + Matching VFD
    2 x Leadshine SPS705 power supplies
    4 x Leadshine Microstep Driver M752
    Spindle V3 Board
    PCPPS bob

    From what I have read on this forum, most of the parts are pretty good (I am only cutting thin wood) but the rails are the big area of issue, mainly from an accuracy point of view. Would that be right?

    Also, back to my original issue, does it look like it comes from the flexing on the y axis?

    Here is a pic...
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Drawing4.jpg 
Views:	139 
Size:	18.4 KB 
ID:	10494

    If I feed too fast the red points end up being curved rather than a sharp right angle?

    I don’t think putting it back on ebay is not an option at the moment though - Not sure how much it would fetch but for the price I paid I wouldn't be able to buy a decent complete machine to replace it. I also really enjoy using it at the moment and feel like I am learning lots every time I fire it up.

    Cheers,

    Jim
    Last edited by cncJim; 24-10-2013 at 02:02 PM.

  8. #8
    Hi Jim

    I have used this little program for several years.


    You may find the following link useful.....
    Straight beams with constant cross sections (Straight beam)


    MITCalc is a small Easy to use tool for calculating beam strength and more importantly deflection. It should help you to understand how "floppy" a steel bar really is. Don't confuse strength and deflection. For most machine design deflection is the enemy, as you have found out your 20mm bars easily support the spindle they will never fail in bending. They do however sag and deflect under load.


    Many years ago time ago I helped my uncle and a mate restore a 6 cylinder car engine with a cast iron block. we re bored and honed the cylinders to size. While he was testing the bore size he placed a micrometre across the bore longitudinally that is along the block and adjusted it until it just held by its own weight in the bore. He then placed his two index fingers on each side of the particular cylinder and pressed hard. The micrometer fell out. That was my first lesson about steel deflection. a heavy casting is not immune to it.


    Get a free trial version of the "beam" module and try it out Only a few Euros if you like it. (I have no connection with the company.)


    The program will give the deflection at various points along the length of the beam for a point load, as with a router. This is a static load calculation tool, meaning it does not allow for vibrating or moving loads. Software to do that is not for the feint hearted. My solution is to add a reasonable margin of safety.


    Please refer to Beam (structure) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    Note the different kinds of supports..... Use the fixed setting in MITCalc for firmly attached ends. Although steel fixings also flex a bit!


    Experiment with different beam depths and widths. MITCalc will allow you enter your own RHS sections You can also enter your 20 and 25mm bar and compare that to other sections.


    Regards
    John
    Last edited by John McNamara; 24-10-2013 at 03:11 PM.

  9. #9
    How about some pics of the actual machine to see if it is possible to modify it?
    Neil...

    Build log...here

  10. #10
    cncJim's Avatar
    Lives in Reading, United Kingdom. Last Activity: 2 Weeks Ago Has been a member for 4-5 years. Has a total post count of 170. Received thanks 15 times, giving thanks to others 32 times.
    Thank you John - Very interesting, I will check out MITCalc.

    I will upload a pic or two tonight!

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. plasma advise sought, want to make a a3-a2 sized machine
    By nobby in forum Plasma Table Machines
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 16-07-2014, 02:53 PM
  2. Ancient CNC machine- advice needed!
    By tom_65a in forum Machine Discussion
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 11-05-2014, 11:17 AM
  3. Welding Advise Needed - Can this welder cope?
    By cncJim in forum Welding, Brazing & Equipment
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 20-02-2014, 01:25 PM
  4. Chinese 6040 CNC Router Advise Needed
    By Bob Hepple in forum Chinese Machines
    Replies: 24
    Last Post: 27-11-2013, 12:00 PM
  5. RFQ: help needed to make cnc machine maybe 2-3 and will pay
    By scnc in forum Projects, Jobs & Requests
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 22-11-2012, 12:31 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •