Thread: Linear rail question
Hello to you all!
Long time reader, and I hope soon to be builder.
Just have a quick question.. You lot seem to hate/dislike the "V Wheel" way with V bearings and steel profile as a linear guide.
Over at other forums this seems to be the preferred option..
And the supported round rails often get shot down aswell.
This has me looking at the hiwin type rails, but I dont really think I will need it!
What would be the stronger option between supported rails (for example SBR20) and the v wheel solution? Using the standard w2 wheels with 3/8" bore. I realize that much depends on the steel profile, but for the example lets say you use perfect hardened steel in 90degree angle for full contact with the wheel?
The machine Im planning should work with hardwood and plastics.. But overkill is always better if something else shows up!
Last edited by Wal; 19-08-2015 at 05:39 PM.
The Following User Says Thank You to Wal For This Useful Post:
I suppose it comes down to a few things really...how much you're prepared to spend, what you're going to do with the machine, whst you want to cut, how often you're going to use it, the accuracy you want from the machine. If you want to make pcb's every other weekend with the odd bit of V carving plaques/signs then V wheels will be fine. If you're wanting to make money from it making aluminium parts then they're the wrong thing....its horses for courses.
If you look at my rambling build you'll see i started out with skate bearings and unsupported pipe and the gantry made from 25mm Sq aluminium box section...what I've ended up with is something way different...but then the things I want to cut have expanded as I've seen what CNC Routers are capable of.....Neil...
Tanks for the input! And I do understand that it would be stupid to underbuild!
This would be a hobby machine doing mostly hardwood routing. That beeing said you are probably right that I would find more uses for the machine!
But from what I understand you need a pretty rigid machine to route oak and similar wood?
I have been reading alot! Hiwin hgr20 seems to be everyones choice. Ive read that 15 is to small.. Is this purely in hight or is it width aswell? How about the egr series?
Or even better for the wallet, chinese hiwin copies.. How do those match upp?
Been looking at iko and thk aswell but they seem to have alot of series with only two ballraces and i guess that this inte ideal?
That pic explains the problem very well. ..Clive..Clive
I understand the problem, but why doesnt ppl just use 25mm rail and thinner ballscrew?
If you use 1204 ballscrews with bk/bf10 you would get 3mm extra for ballnut clearence and just have to make a bracket?
Or am I missing something vital? :D
Maching slots for clearence while trouble some if not kitted up to mill the slots does give the advantage of reducing weight without sacrificing too much strength. The lighter and shallower 20mm setup gives a very strong and low profile setup making for a nice balanced Z axis.
Either way would work.! Thou IMO the 20mm rails with lighter plate setup gives better balance of strength and acceleration/speed with nema23 motors.
By j2sip in forum Rails, Guideways & BearingsReplies: 5Last Post: 18-07-2014, 11:00 PM
By Musht in forum Open Source Designs & PlansReplies: 0Last Post: 15-06-2012, 11:21 AM
By alanb in forum Items WantedReplies: 4Last Post: 21-07-2010, 06:10 PM
FOR SALE: Linear rail and bearingBy black5f in forum Items For SaleReplies: 5Last Post: 02-07-2010, 06:23 PM
By IN-WondeR in forum Rails, Guideways & BearingsReplies: 20Last Post: 05-02-2010, 11:25 AM