Rotating Ballnut - design ideas

[JAZZCNC]

Is there a case for using the direct driven screw with a bigger motor? You are saving the cost and complexity of the 2:1 drive and halving the speed required from the motor, so running it in it's higher torque region anyway?

Kit

Can do either but using a larger motor usually doesn't cost less because requires larger drive and often more volts so larger PSU.
However, on long machines rotating nut wins hands down and requires a belt connection, so the ratio is no extra cost. Rotating the screw on the long machine means much larger ballscrew is required and this really starts to ramp up the costs because everything scales up with it, Bearings, couplers, motors, drives, PSU
Even then a rotating the screw system cannot achieve the feeds a rotating nut can.