Panel Mount Voltage Regulator / Knob

[Robin Hewitt]

I'd still go with the LM338T, it might run a tadge warm but it's so cheap and easy. Heck, just PM me a mailing address and I'll send you a freebie

[irving2008]

I'd still go with the LM338T, it might run a tadge warm but it's so cheap and easy. Heck, just PM me a mailing address and I'll send you a freebie

Robin, it'll run rather more than warm. On a decent 4degC/W heatsink the dissipation limit is 12.5W (at 25degC ambient) so at 20v input and 5V output the allowable output current before it goes into thermal shutdown is less than 800mA, rising to 2.5A at 15v output. Maximum output would be 18.8v at 5A.

Also there's no current limit, only short circuit protection, again not meeting expectations...

I'm not saying that you couldn't use this, and its cheap and simple, but Lee will have to downgrade his expectations and thats not making best use of his 160VA transformer when a 50VA would do.

regards,
Irving...

[Robin Hewitt]

Robin, it'll run rather more than warm. On a decent 4degC/W heatsink the dissipation limit is 12.5W

OTOH if he's bolting it to an aluminium enclosure he's going to get heaps better than 4degC/W.

I'm not saying there isn't anything "better", but does this particular pudding really require that many eggs?

[irving2008]

OTOH if he's bolting it to an aluminium enclosure he's going to get heaps better than 4degC/W.

I'm not saying there isn't anything "better", but does this particular pudding really require that many eggs?

4degC/W is 300 sq cm of 1.5mm ali sheet held vertically and supported at corners only - I'd be surprised if the enclosure gave anything close to around 10degC/W - aluminium boxes are incredibly poor heatsinks (the type of alloy used makes a huge difference as well).

[Eddy]

A small fan will do wonders for heat dissipation. You can pick up small fans that are 5v and 12v at several surplus shops.

I placed a 50mm fan over a dual 15A motor controller with no heatsink and it kept it sufficiently cool even at the full 15A pull. The most current I could pull with a heatsink and no fan was about 8-9A.

Eddy
www.wrighthobbies.net

[irving2008]

A small fan will do wonders for heat dissipation. You can pick up small fans that are 5v and 12v at several surplus shops.

I placed a 50mm fan over a dual 15A motor controller with no heatsink and it kept it sufficiently cool even at the full 15A pull. The most current I could pull with a heatsink and no fan was about 8-9A.

Eddy
www.wrighthobbies.net

You are indeed correct, however there is a world of difference between a pulse width modulated motor controller with a high peak current but low RMS value and a linear regulator with a constant high dissipation.

[Eddy]

You are indeed correct, however there is a world of difference between a pulse width modulated motor controller with a high peak current but low RMS value and a linear regulator with a constant high dissipation.

You missed my point. The motor controller has to dissipate the heat caused by the voltage loss of the high and low side Vsat. A loss of 2V at 15A is 30 watts of heat to dissipate per IC (there's 2 on the board), a total of 60 watts with no heatsink. The movement of the air across the surface of the IC and the PCB is able to dissipate the 60 watts.

Eddy