Small rigid router - Design advise needed

[Blackrat]

ja ja wat se jy :P

why even go with belts ? are you going to have a step down ratio ?

i wouldnt bother with the 3rd rail, i think it will just make it harder to clock up ...

what or how are the two bottom rectangle tubes fastened ?

looking good :D

[EddyCurrent]

Looks pretty good but to make life easier later I would draw in your energy chain, drag chain, whatever you call it because it could affect some aspects of the design such as , mounting brackets, length of travel in X direction. Also consider limit switches and homing switches locations.

[mitchejc]

Thanks for the advice EddyCurrent. I will start adding those as I can see it might be an issue with the design as it is now, especially the drag chain running on or behind the gantry.

Looks pretty good but to make life easier later I would draw in your energy chain, drag chain, whatever you call it because it could affect some aspects of the design such as , mounting brackets, length of travel in X direction. Also consider limit switches and homing switches locations.

[Blackrat]

belts aint gonna make it any smoother .... id run a coupler on the two axis' , so much easier and cheaper

im not quite with you on bolting it to a table ? you HAVE to join either sides , no ways you going to cut ally decently if they are seperate from each other, not to mention the nightmare of trying to get them parallel by clamping to a table

[Clive S]

I am no expert but if you follow this forum and take notice of the Master's on here, coupling with belts helps to eliminate resonance which can stop a motor dead in its tracks. Try running a stepper with a loose mounting to see the effect. ..Clive

[mitchejc]

Thanks for the feedback Blackrat. I also like the simplicity of direct drive but quite a few people here believe belt-drive is the better route. I don't know how much better?

The table/base will be a very sturdy steel frame so the two sides are build separately but when bolted down they are connected via the base or am I maybe misunderstanding your question. I guess I can also weld them to the table but that won't be much stronger than having several bolts on each side of both or will it? I thought bolting them would make the alignment easier.

belts aint gonna make it any smoother .... id run a coupler on the two axis' , so much easier and cheaper

im not quite with you on bolting it to a table ? you HAVE to join either sides , no ways you going to cut ally decently if they are seperate from each other, not to mention the nightmare of trying to get them parallel by clamping to a table

[EddyCurrent]

With regard to the base, you need to post some drawings I think. With anything, you need good solid foundations to build from.

[mitchejc]

Yep, you are right, I'll do the drawing for the base and post it as its obviously an integral part of the design.

With regard to the base, you need to post some drawings I think. With anything, you need good solid foundations to build from.

[Blackrat]

The table/base will be a very sturdy steel frame so the two sides are build separately but when bolted down they are connected via the base

thats not going to work

no ways you gonna bolt it together so that the rails come out within a decent tolerance ....
have a read about epoxy leveling a frame if you havnt already ?

[mitchejc]

I'll try and get the drawings done, but the picture I have in mind is basically a 4 legged steel tube structure made from 80x80 tubing with lots of support under the table and space inside where I can sandbag the whole thing to add lots of weight to the base. I then epoxy level the top of the steel base to get that flat, bolt 2 layers of good quality birch ply + a 5mm steel sheet on top. Then bolt the gantry sides to that surface and epoxy level them before the rails go on. Does it sound practical or are there an easier way to build a sturdy base. I started off with the idea to do a concrete slab on top of a steel structure but there's just to many issues with that approach.

thats not going to work

no ways you gonna bolt it together so that the rails come out within a decent tolerance ....
have a read about epoxy leveling a frame if you havnt already ?