New router build advice...

[Boyan Silyavski]

So please don't comment until you have experienced a vertical machine.!

It's a forum and i will comment as much as i feel the need to. It's my opinion, grownups could decide for themselves. I am a final user and use my machine daily for various jobs, from high volume production to making the odd sign, from aluminum, all plastics to foam. So lets say i know a bit about what i am talking. I know about the vertical machine of yours from a long time but i have never felt the need of one. There is one main reason i did not mention- dealing with dust. Dust from wood and dust from foam and plastics. Many times on an odd job dust shoe could not be used. You know i make custom dust shoes so if i say so, its so, not that i don't have a proper extraction. Then only gravity keeps foam or plastic dust from flying around. In fact that's what one of the main reasons to make my machine with raised sides and low bed.

What you are saying to me is like i say to you : Please don't comment, you sell machines you know nothing of what the final user really needs. I will not say that, lo lets keep civil here.


You may know a lot but what, other people can not say their opinions? Its same on the thread about the controllers. I am just suggesting other options. Not 2 people use the machines they have in the same way, so more options, the better.

[JAZZCNC]

It's a forum and i will comment as much as i feel the need to. It's my opinion, grownups could decide for themselves. I am a final user and use my machine daily for various jobs, from high volume production to making the odd sign, from aluminum, all plastics to foam. So lets say i know a bit about what i am talking.

I never said don't comment, I said Don't comment on what you do not know about. You have never used a Vertical machine or even seen a vertical machine in use so how can you advise someone not to go that route.?

Maybe it's a language barrier thing but like the Controller thread you mention, your comments are worded such that it comes across as your way is the only way and only your way is the correct way.!. .Well it's not my friend and this needs to be pointed out.

In that thread, my comments were to let others know that a PC works just fine I never advised on any best way or controller. I gave my opinion on what I used and way, also why I personally didn't like the DDSV after trying it.

I didn't tell anyone not to use it and I certainly didn't advise anyone not to use or buy a controller that I've had no previous personal experience off or in fact even know anyone who has like you did with your comment on the vertical machine advise.
You'll never find me commenting or advising anyone to build or buy something I've not built or tried my self and suggest you and others do the same. Because while you think your helping your actually not if you have had no previous experience of the product, what you are actually doing is potentially swaying people in a direction that may not be the best for them.
By all means comment and give your opinion but please shut the f'#k up when it comes to telling them NOT to take a route you have never been down.!